Wendell Berry photo
1986 photo of Wendell Berry

For several years as a correspondent for the Kansas City Times in the mid-1980s, I explored the enormous area we called “rural America” — a collection of places, as varied as you could imagine and only distantly related to common city and suburb dwellers’ notions of what non-metropolitan life was like.

I’d long been a fan of Wendell Berry’s work. His human-centric essays, poetry, and fiction enriched my life over the years. His seminal nonfiction work, The Unsettling of America: Culture & Agriculture, was a call, among other things, for returning to a more traditional style of agriculture and moving away from the factory farming that was not just pushing people off the land but risking our future. While he wasn’t widely known, he was influential in the best ways — and I knew I had to include him in a series of articles I was working on about a rural economy in perpetual turmoil and people’s lives as they dealt with wrenching changes.

So, one morning in the early summer of 1986, I drove up to his farmhouse in Port Royal, Kentucky for an hours-long conversation. Of course he was eloquent and deep. But he was also kind and patient.

My notes from that conversation have long disappeared, but the article I wrote about it remains in the Times archives. His words then were profound, even prophetic, and they are no less so today. Here’s an excerpt:

“There’s supposed to be a great religious concern in this country now, an upwelling of interest in religion,” he said. “But it’s piety without reverence.

“People who have no reverence will destroy a mountain to get the coal out of it or destroy a field to get a crop out of it. They’ll make extravagant assumptions about their own competence and intelligence, and they’ll make extravagant mistakes.

“The natural result of reverence is humility. Humility in agriculture, as in the other uses of nature, results in smallness of scale and modesty of means.

“If a person farms a farm on the assumption that his intelligence is somehow equal to it, he’ll take chances on the weather and he’ll plow out his waterways. If a farmer farms with the assumption that he isn’t equal, he’ll use it humbly and leave the waterways in, just in case there’s a cloudburst.

“The humble farmer tries to align himself with nature, and the arrogant farmer tries to replace nature’s intelligence with his own.”

Rest in peace.

(I took the photo on Berry’s front porch. It’s one of my favorites, and he liked it so much that he used it in the jacket sleeve for one of his later books.)

There goes the NY Times again, downplaying the reality of what Trump/Vance stand for. “Combative conservatism” is bended-knee journalistic weakness, and this “Political Memo” is standard-issue in the genre the Times has mastered. (I’m not linking to it.)

The reality of Trump/Vance is that they are planning a dictatorship. They’ve made that absolutely clear. They are, for all practical purposes, outright fascists.

Just pathetic, and also the standard at the Times (and many other big “news” organizations at this point)…

Note: The reporter’s byline comes with this hilarious addendum: “Michael C. Bender traveled on Senator JD Vance’s campaign plane this week for events in Georgia, Michigan and Wisconsin.” Yeah, that qualifies him to make this judgment.

Topics in the latest edition of my “Cornerstone of democracy” newsletter — a compendium of the best of political reporting/commentary (and more) — include:

— Best debate commentary
— Real fact-checking
— Texas city’s war on women (and anyone who helps them)
— Parents of dead child eviscerate extremists

I curate to save you time. Please subscribe (it’s free), and let other folks know about it.

Let me know about great work I’ve missed.

Again, that link: https://cornerstone.ghost.io/essentials-september-11-2024/

This first appeared in my “Cornerstone of Democracy” newsletter.

Reporters WIthout Borders map of press freedom shows US is a "problematic situation"
Reporters Without Borders press freedom index

The publisher of the New York Times posted an essay, warning of a war on the press if Trump re-takes the White House. A.G. Sulzberger is the latest member of his family (which holds controlling shares in the company) to be in charge there. In his piece, he gave a vivid description of how Hungary’s prime minister (read: dictator), Viktor Orban, has taken control of the media through a series of moves that all but destroyed freedom of the press there. Trump and his apparatchiks, said Sulzberger, were likely planning the same kind of moves.

Then came the disclaimer that undermined everything else he wrote – and showed once again what a feckless, timid organization he leads.

As someone who strongly believes in the foundational importance of journalistic independence, I have no interest in wading into politics. I disagree with those who have suggested that the risk Trump poses to the free press is so high that news organizations such as mine should cast aside neutrality and directly oppose his reelection. It is beyond shortsighted to give up journalistic independence out of fear that it might later be taken away. At The Times, we are committed to following the facts and presenting a full, fair and accurate picture of November’s election and the candidates and issues shaping it. Our democratic model asks different institutions to play different roles; this is ours.

At the same time, as the steward of one of the country’s leading news organizations, I feel compelled to speak out about threats to the free press, as my predecessors and I have done to leaders of both parties. I am doing so here, in the pages of an esteemed competitor, because I believe the risk is shared by our entire profession, as well as all who depend on it. In highlighting this campaign, I am not advising people how to vote. There are countless issues on the ballot that are closer to voters’ hearts than protections for my broadly unpopular profession. But the weakening of a free and independent press matters, whatever your party or politics. The flow of trustworthy news and information is critical to a free, secure and prosperous nation. This is why defense of the free press has been a point of rare bipartisan consensus throughout the nation’s history. As President Ronald Reagan put it: “There is no more essential ingredient than a free, strong, and independent press to our continued success in what the Founding Fathers called our ‘noble experiment’ in self-government.”

Press critics are already tearing this apart, and rightly so. Sulzberger is simply lying when he claims the Times has been “following the facts and presenting a full, fair and accurate picture of November’s election and the candidates and issues shaping it.” No major journalism organization has done more in the past few years to normalize Trump – who has vowed to be a dictator, for god’s sake – and extremism. Its political coverage has been disgracefully shabby and shallow, with some noteworthy exceptions, for decades. If the Times maintained its “journalistic independence” by relentlessly doing its job, that would be a huge improvement.

It wouldn’t be nearly enough, however.

Sulzberger can’t wrap his privileged mind around something that feels obvious to me, but which is plainly a non-starter in the highest ranks of American media. When one candidate and party are out to kill democracy, journalism will automatically be on the hit list if they take power. The first, most existential threat is not to journalism. It is to democracy.

Which is why I’ve begged journalists to be activists for democracy. Some already are, but sadly, most are unwilling to connect these dots. At any rate, the Times is definitely not going to do it. At the Times, activism is reserved for mounting an all-hands-on-deck campaign pushing the incumbent president out of the race.

Sulzberger is engaging in a liberal New Yorker’s fantasy when he imagines that his news organization would survive in any useful way if right-wing extremists take over our government. He and his team may have studied Hungary and other “authoritarian” states’ destruction of the press, but they have plainly not learned much.

They will learn this, though, if the worst happens this fall: When fascists take over, journalists have two choices. They can collaborate with the regime. Or they can join the resistance.

Topics in the latest edition of my “Cornerstone of democracy” newsletter — a compendium of the best of political reporting/commentary (and more) — include:

— catharsis in Chicago
— what’s at stake
— voting rights
— capitalism at its worst
— crap fact-checking

I curate to save you time. Please subscribe (it’s free), and let me know about great work I’ve missed.

Six years ago I begged journalists to “stop being loudspeakers for liars” — and I have to admit that my entreaties fell on deaf ears.

Last week’s lie-filled “press conference” at Trump’s home was a powerful demonstration of why journalists should at least try to deal with a situation they encounter again and again and again. But they’ve made it clear that they will never even acknowledge this fundamental flaw in what they do, much less do anything to repair the ongoing damage.

I guess it’s hopeless but I keep hoping that the craft will someday recognize what damage it’s doing to all of us.

……rests on the foundation of an educated electorate.”

That’s a line from Thomas Jefferson, and it’s also the title of my new newsletter. Its purpose is to showcase the best political journalism I can find.

This means you won’t see horse-race or both-sides BS. No poll stories, either. Just the good stuff, the meaningful stuff.

It’s journalism that illuminates what’s at stake, what the candidates say they’ll do, and who they are beyond the superficial gloss.

Here’s yesterday’s edition:

https://cornerstone.ghost.io/essentials-august-7-2024/

Please help me make this work. Send me links to articles/videos etc. that you believe fulfill the mission I’ve set out.

And let me know how all this strikes you.

Big Journalism has all but ignored a staggeringly terrible Trump campaign “promise” — treating it as another “there he goes again” story that disappears quickly.

What’s it this time? Trump, who’s become more and more visibly anti-vax, upped the ante the other day. He said he’d block funding for public schools that require kids to have been vaccinated against common, deadly — and preventable — childhood diseases.

This isn’t merely a sop to the most radically ignorant part of the Trump voting base. It’s a promise to kill countless people. It’s utterly depraved.

Read this from Radley Balko to see just how depraved.

If Harris said something like this, our news media would hound her — properly — for such a reckless vow. With Trump, our journalists just move onto the next outrage.

I have to ask, again, what the hell is wrong with journalists that they handle such important stories so casually.

NY Times headline /deck: 

The Beginning of Biden’s Long Farewell

In a speech from the Oval Office, President Biden said it was time to “pass the torch to a new generation.” But he said nothing about his own age or capacity that led so many Democrats to desert him.The NY Times expanded on its institutional arrogance with Peter Baker’s “analysis” — a word used by journalists to avoid admitting that the work is opinion — of the Biden speech.

Baker is, IMO, among the worst of the worst in Big Journalism political coverage. No one has done more in recent years to normalize Trump world extremism. He was also an enthusiastic member of the Times gang, spanning the opinion and news pages, that campaigned for Biden to withdraw from the race.

His sour-grapes “analysis” tells you much more about Baker than Biden. What it tells you is that he and his publication are not only chest-thumping about Biden’s withdrawal, but have another bone to pick, namely that the president is insufficiently contrite.

Baker is apparently pissed off that Biden had the temerity not to confess to the American people the old-guy incompetence the Times made central to its case. Between Baker’s lines, Biden should also be apologizing to the Times.

Baker has been a crappy journalist for years. His piece demonstrates that he’s also a consummate jerk. Ditto for the editors who published and promoted it.

The most obvious takeaway from the “Attaboy Joe” editorials and commentaries is not that they’re offering sincere thanks for a fine president’s selfless act.

No, they’re congratulating themselves, having played a central role in hounding him off the ticket. They’re feeling powerful now.

Keep that in mind, because they like the idea that they can exert power from their safe perches, outside the arena where they take no risks, and are never held accountable for their epic failures. But they only even attempt to do this kind of thing with Democrats. Republicans hold journalism in pure contempt. A lot journalists — perhaps rationally — act as though they are physically afraid of the consequence of telling truth to right-wing power. They know Democrats are too civilized to do more than complain.

God, I want journalism that respects the people it claims to serve.