Cross-posted from my Cornerstone of Democracy newsletter…

On January 20, 2025, one of the supremely dangerous people in American history will re-occupy the White House, reclaiming all of the awesome powers of the presidency. Donald Trump and his extreme right-wing apparatchiks will issue a blizzard of executive orders, all designed to reverse decades of social, economic, environmental, and political progress – and to punish Americans who’ve had the temerity to challenge him and his cult.

That will be Day One of a saga all too likely to see the end of the brave, vital American experiment in government of the people, by the people, and for the people.

The Trump/Vance regime will be backed by a rubber-stamping right-wing Senate (maybe also the House) and Supreme Court; corporate oligarchs including fossil fuel barons and tech monopolists; right-wing media operations that use lies and propaganda to keep the cult angry and compliant; generals and police chiefs eager to round up immigrants and dissidents, and to bust heads of anyone who objects; and cadres of armed-to-the-teeth civilian brownshirts just waiting for the boss to cut the leash.

By the time they’re finished, democracy may exist in name only. We could soon be ruled by autocrats whose fascist beliefs become the ugliest realities.

I hope I am wrong about this. I would be ecstatic to be wrong. But if I’m right, or even close, we are veering into catastrophic times – into a violent, corrupt, extremist era that renders our nation unrecognizable, all too quickly, and throws the entire world into destructive chaos.

If we are facing such a nightmare, journalists will have a simple, if agonizing, choice: Acquiesce to the regime. Or join the resistance.

It makes me deeply sad to believe that most journalists will stick with what they have done for years now: business as usual. Or, I should say, malpractice as usual. The consistent failure of our top political journalists and their organizations has been deliberate failure. They have relentlessly normalized extremism, and in this election they outright refused to seriously confront the implications of vicious right-wing rule in America, much less lift a finger to prevent it.

The majority of journalists, I believe, will maintain the “neutrality” that has been so destructive to democracy. So as they sit in their above-it-all perches and watch the catastrophic whirlwind, they’ll amplify the lies and hate from Trump and his allies, downplay the havoc that results from the regime’s hard-line policies, and pretend that they are just doing their jobs as observers, assuming they’re not the ones in the firing line. That choice – and pretense – will be understandable. It will be profoundly wrong, not least because democracy and the rule of law are preconditions for freedom of the press. It will also be profoundly dishonorable.

Don’t expect any of our major media organizations to resist. There will be some brave individuals who try to keep a sense of honor even if their bosses won’t. But let’s be practical. The billionaire owners of the Washington Post and Los Angeles Times bowed ahead of time to the extremists, figuring (accurately as it turned out) that the risk of Trump’s wrath was bad for their main (i.e. not news) businesses.

We can’t talk about major media organizations without special attention to the New York Times. It is America’s most influential journalism company, and it has been the singular example of how a place teeming with talented journalists can make itself a weak-kneed supplicant to the wealth and power of the new order. No major journalism organization has shown more sympathy to extremism than the Times. No top news operation has done more to treat the most consequential election in our lifetimes as just another horse race featuring “both sides” coverage that mocks the vital role of honest journalism.

It’s telling that the Times’ editor and publisher, in recent interviews, have stressed how the Times has deployed a team to study how 21st Century autocrats in fallen democracies had brought the press to heel. Was the Times engaged in this learning process to figure out how to stop if from happening? There’s not a shred of evidence for that. Rather, as will undoubtedly become clear, the so-called “Paper of Record” was figuring out how to get cozy enough with a new Trump regime to survive and (financially) thrive.

Oh, sure, the Times editorial page will still dislike Trump (though I expect shifts in tone to appease him). Meanwhile, the rancidly terrible Times political “news” operation will continue to ever-so-politely chronicle his regime as if it was simply chronicling the winning party’s actions after a disagreement among fair, well-minded people. Worse, much of the “mainstream media” follows the lead of the Times. Unfortunately, the Times will be an adept – and historically ignominious – leader of Vichy journalism.

Some journalists, meanwhile, will choose honor. They will embrace the difficult and risky job of resisting.

They will need help. Lots of it.

They will need financial support, because corporate America will be even less interested in paying for journalism with integrity.

They will need legal support, because Trump and the new oligarchs are already adopting tactics from the playbook of dictators like Hungary’s Victor Orban – abusing the legal system, capturing the courts, and so much more that has turned a once free press there into a collection of vassals.

They will need technical support, because Trump will use the power of the state – and he will count on the willing compliance of the tech industry – to spy on, harass, and prosecute journalists and their sources. Whistleblowers will need more protection than ever, and unless journalists have the means to help provide it, daring to reveal wrongdoing from the inside will go from risky to downright dangerous.

It seems improbable, at best, that traditional media organizations will suddenly decide to find the spines they’ve put in deep storage. I’ll gratefully support the ones that do.

More likely, we’re going to need to build journalism – real journalism – up again. We can start by supporting the many smaller organizations (and individuals) that have been working tirelessly to defend democracy, human rights, the environment, and so much more. They will be under relentless pressure to shut up. Help them speak.

We will also need to build media back from the grassroots. The demise of local newspapers has given oxygen to the right-wing propagandists. We have to rebuild, one community at a time.

I’ll be doing what I can to help.

Topics in the latest edition of my “Cornerstone of democracy” newsletter — a compendium of the best of political reporting/commentary (and more) — include:

— Trump/Vance, beyond cynical
— Corruption the norm in Trump world
— Attacking truth tellers
— War’s latest front
— More on third parties

I curate to save you time. Please subscribe (it’s free), and let other folks know about it.

Let me know about great work I’ve missed.

 

Topics in the latest edition of my “Cornerstone of democracy” newsletter — a compendium of the best of political reporting/commentary (and more) — include:

— Dems find their spines
— Trump world corruption
— Age matters
— Musk loves Trump
— Musk hates free speech

I curate to save you time. Please subscribe (it’s free), and let other folks know about it.

Let me know about great work I’ve missed.

Topics in the latest edition of my “Cornerstone of democracy” newsletter — a compendium of the best of political reporting/commentary (and more) — include:

— Convention coda
— Did someone mention climate?
— RFKjr: sad
— Antitrust action on rentals
— A mother’s message

I curate to save you time. Please subscribe (it’s free), and let other folks know about it.

Let me know about great work I’ve missed.

 

Lawrence O’Donnell’s commentary last night is a reminder that our “mainstream” political journalists have learned exactly nothing from their ongoing failures over the years. It was “2016 all over again,” he said of the TV “news” channels’ live broadcast of the lie-filled “press conference” Trump hosted at his Florida resort. “To make a bad news coverage situation worse,” O’Donnell said, “none of the networks – none of them – carried Kamala Harris’ speech live after the Trump appearance. None of them.”

None of them did any fact checking during the Trump fiasco, either. There was some feeble after-the-fact checking. but as O’Donnell pointed out, how hard would it have been to use part of the screen during the lie fest to point out at least some of the lies? It would have been simple.

What accounts for this ongoing failure? Money. Trump gooses ratings and is pure clickbait. Our news organizations have stopped even pretending otherwise. Which means they’ve stopped pretending – not that they ever really did – to do journalism.

I feel an abiding contempt for Big Journalism these days, especially the TV news channels. The Murdoch family’s vile Fox “News” at least makes no pretense about its scumbaggery. The others do make a pretense of doing actual journalism, and it’s all just theater. Except this is theater that could help lead to dictatorship.

Today’s Washington Post has another reminder that it’s all corruption, all the time in Trump world.

For reasons I can’t fathom, however, Big Journalism treats his serial scandals as one-offs. This piece from the Washington Post is an example of brilliant reporting with insufficient context.

It’s baffling that journalists can’t be bothered to pull it all together — to show the staggering breadth and depth of the Trump world sleaze.

Our news media notice some of the brush fires. But they never notice (or tell the rest of us) that the entire forest is ablaze.

Most journalists have an admirable instinct to be fair to the people they cover. But it often emerges as the traditional “both-sides” approach, which has become discredited in an era when one side consistently lies.

It’s especially absurd when quoting both sides means giving deceitful people a forum to change the subject and launch yet more lies.

A case in point is this, from the Washington Post. In the screenshot below is a quote from the story (labeled “analysis” — the dodge journalism uses to insert opinion into what is allegedly straight news coverage).From Washington Post opinion piece: In a text message, the Trump campaign declined to answer whether Trump truly believes his claims about electric boats and, if not, why he is continuing to repeat falsehoods about them. “The Washington Post is a pathetic institution no longer worth the paper it’s printed on and they should be embarrassed for wasting time writing a story about boats sinking when our country is sinking from Joe Biden and Kamala Harris’s failed leadership,” Trump campaign spokeswoman Karoline Leavitt wrote.

It’s important to note that the Post’s instinct in this piece is good. It wants to not just debunk one of Trump’s often-repeated fairy tales, but to explain — with facts from people who know what they’re talking about — why what he says is nonsensical garbage.

But when it asks for comment from the campaign, the Trump apparatchik responds with an attack that doesn’t even attempt to address the question, as you can see from the screnshot above.

There is zero need to publish that response verbatim.

The appropriate way to handle the Trump campaign non-response would be something like this:

“A campaign spokesperson replied to the Post’s query with an attack on the news organization. She did not address the questions we asked.”

That’s it. Don’t do stenography for liars. No one benefits, except the liar.

(h/t https://mastodon.social/@waldoj — https://mastodon.social/@waldoj/112861853467127984)

NY Times home page full of more anti-Biden stories.The screenshot above is today’s installment in the New York Times’ all-hands-on-deck campaign to get Biden to withdraw.

I want to emphasize — again — that I do not object to news organizations’ taking a stand on a matter they consider important and then pushing their view relentlessly as advocates — in news articles and commentary alike. Advocacy journalism is vital, if it’s done ethically. This isn’t even close.

Advocacy journalism, done with integrity, requires transparency. The Times keeps pretending that it’s still an impartial conveyor of what people need to know. It is not on this matter, not even close, and it refuses to be transparent — not just about doing it, but crucially who’s giving the orders and what the motivations are. Shades of the 2016 Clinton emails saga, when the Times went on a wildly dishonest binge.

Advocacy journalism also requires context. In this case, the context is stark and scary: Trump is visibly deranged, and it’s accelerating. So are his stated plans — with the backing of one of the two major political parties (including its wholly owned Supreme Court) and an army of cultists — to create a fascist America.

The Times has been, for a long time, the nation’s most important news outlet. Other journalism organizations take the Times’ lead in what national news, notably politics, that they cover and publish. The Times has disproportionate clout, and has frequently abused it.

I beg the Times to redirect its advocacy, and soon — by relentlessly making clear to its own audience, and more broadly via its influence in journalism’s broader community — the emergency it has, so far, only discussed as just one more interesting topic among many. We are on the verge of the end of the American experiment. Obsess on that, please, before it’s too late.